How to hand it over to a qualified contractor By Brenda Ordonez
Doing show business in the 1990s means running leaner and meaner in theface of competition that is stiffer than ever before. It means entertainingideas that never would have occurred to a show producer in, say 1980. Likeoutsourcing exhibit space sales.
During his three decades as a show producer Hugh MacGregor never consideredoutsourcing booth sales. It's not that he was opposed to the idea of hiringan independent contractor to sell booth space. It was simply, MacGregorsays, a concept that was "never contemplated." Launching hisshow career with MacLean-Hunter in Canada in 1964, he went on to form hisown company in the mid '70s. In 1988, he sold it to Reed Expositions Co.,where he stayed on as Executive Vice President for three years.
"We trained staff in-house in all facets of show management,"MacGregor says. "The salesperson had to be wellrounded. It took abouttwo years for a person to become knowledgeable about the show industry.I couldn't imagine doing that outside the company."
Now President of Sable Productions 2000 LC in Marco Island, FL, MacGregoris virtually a one-person sales "team" for his second-year event,The Marketing Show, held in Fort Lauderdale. Would he look at outsourcingbooth sales now? "Yes. I'm not stuck with the notion it won't work."
Though he's not from Missouri, MacGregor would take a "show-me"approach -- he would have to be convinced that the independent contractorcould become thoroughly knowledgeable about his show and could answer exhibitors'questions with a level of expertise. "They would have to know theaudience attending the show and the exhibitors' expectations. Our productis the audience we deliver, what we give to the exhibitor. If they canpresent that element of the show fairly, that's really what the exhibitorwants to hear. The salesperson has to be prepared to answer a plethoraof questions."
Handing over the baby
For many show managers, outsourcing the booth sales function to anoutside contractor would be as wrenching as sending a child off to daycarefor the first time.
"There is a sense of ownership -- as there should be -- and it'shard to allow someone outside to have that empowerment," says LeeLanghorst, a former show manager who runs Show Success, an outsourcingcompany based in Lake Villa, IL.
His is one of several new independent outsourcing businesses begunin response to the growing need for space sales help among not only associationshow managers but also for-profit producers.
Early on, associations took up the outsourcing banner as a way to produceshows without overburdening existing staff or incurring the expense ofadding staff. They found ready-made sales expertise through several for-profitshow companies agreeable to contracting out the services of their in-house,trained sales staff.
Most notable of these for length of show experience is George LittleManagement Inc., a 70-year-old company based in White Plains, NY. A strongindication of the deepening trend toward outsourcing is the company's activesolicitation of association business. According to Tony Lee, Vice President,Sales and Marketing, it recently established a Washington, D.C. officespecifically for that purpose and has begun advertising to the industry.
Joan Hall, President of Joan Hall & Associates LLC, an outsourcingcompany in Fairfield, CT, says that since her company start-up six monthsago, she has added five new employees. Right now, she notes, most of herbusiness comes from associations.
"Ninety percent of show management is selling," says MacGregor.Nowhere is that more evident than at independent show companies who succeedor fail by the bottom-line. They have always been more reluctant to handtheir "babies" over to those outside the company.
"We have always handled booth sales in house for our own showsand for those we manage for others," says Lee. "Our own showsare primarily in the gift and homeware industries. We looked at outsourcing,but we feel we know the shows and the industry better than anyone. We feelwe're better off getting people from that particular industry. It's easierand quicker to train them to be salespeople than to be industry knowledgeable.You can only get that from experience."
Michael O'Loughlin, Marketing Manager at O'Loughlin Trade Shows Inc.,a family-run company in Portland, OR, echoes Lee's assessment: "Wetried outsourcing and found that the contractor didn't have any betterexhibitor contacts than we have. We haven't found a group that's betterat selling than we are." To be fair, though, O'Loughlin says as muchas 50 percent of the sales function for his shows, which cover the recreationalvehicle, sportsmen, boat and home and garden industries, are in-personsales calls resulting from years of relationship building with exhibitorsand prospects -- an advantage not typically available to space sales contractors.
Yet, more and more, independent show producers are warming to the ideaof outsourcing sales. Why? "Independent companies have more showsto sell, and its a matter of time management. Though sales are a biggerpiece of the pie for them, they can hire a contractor and focus on otherthings," says Wendy Morris, Vice President of Sales and Marketingfor ExpoVention, an outsourcing company in Great Neck, NY.
But is it cost-effective?
Getting a seasoned show professional when you contract booth salescan be key to making the process cost-effective and, indeed, workable.
In the past two years, a growing number of show managers have launchedtheir own outsourcing businesses. Some, like Langhorst, were caught inthe other '90s trend: downsizing. When Reed Exhibition Companies closedits Chicago office in 1994, Langhorst, a show director for 12 years, wasoffered relocation to Connecticut. He opted instead for severance pay andinvested it in setting up a home office.
"Outsourcing is an opportunity," says Langhorst, "tohire someone basically at the cost of a clerical person, who you don'thave to provide office space and benefits for and who brings to the tablemany years of show experience."
In many cases, Hall points out, show managers can save the costs ofnot just one staff person, but sometimes two or three, especially if bothsales and exhibitor administrative services are outsourced.
Bob Craft, President of Craft & Associates, an outsourcing companyin Columbus, OH, says you can eliminate, too, a lot of the individual frustrationthat usually accompanies in-house selling and collection.
Karen Reynolds-Feld, Expo Group Director for the Business ResourcesDivision of Inc. magazine, relies on an outsourcing company to providesales and exhibitor services for Inc. World, a 350-booth show whose exhibitorsare suppliers to small and emerging companies. However, she concedes that,after researching show companies and looking at bringing people on staff,ultimately it would pay to have an in-house sales staff.
On the other hand, for Sharyl Parker, Director of Marketing for theOregon Restaurant Association in Wilsonville, OR, saving money, while important,was not the only consideration when weighing outsourcing pros and cons.Until this year, she produced the Northwest Food Service Show with onlyone assistant when the association hosted the event every other year --the show rotates between Portland and Seattle, where it is run by the WashingtonRestaurant Association. Now Parker's association has hired the local exhibitsales company that also has been selling booth space for the Seattle event.
"It still costs us more initially to outsource, in that we areadding to the payroll. But what you're really doing is designating wherethe staff needs to spend time," Parker says. "For us it was aclear-cut decision, though one not made easily. In order to carry out ourassociation programs, we were going to have to outsource something; andsince it was the logically separate component, we chose booth sales."
How to do it right
Show managers can readily find outsource companies that will handleevery aspect of managing a show, with choices from a menu of services --as many or as few as needed. These basic guidelines culled from show managersand outsource companies provide a starting point:
Start early Plan to have the contractor in place at least one year in advance ofthe show. This will give you and your "partner" the time neededto work out critical details and adjust to each other before selling begins.The selection process, then, should begin well ahead of time.
Find qualified contractors The tried-and-true methods for finding any show contractor also applyto the sales function: Call other show managers for recommendations andcheck industry membership directories.
Send out an RFP First, determine what services will be outsourced. Is it strictly sales,will the contractor also handle exhibitor administrative services, or willit be a combination of both? Do you want the contractor to do market research,sell sponsorships and other marketing programs, create the exhibitor prospectusand/or handle mailings?
Then, spell out your needs in a Request for Proposal (RFP). If youhave a good idea of how responsibilities will be shared, lay that out inyour RFP. Is there an issue you'd like the bidder to address? For example,you may want to know what the contractor would do about exhibitor attrition.Your RFP should paint a full picture of the show and your requirements,so the contractor can make an informed bid.
Your RFP should ask bidders to provide this essential information:
Company background, how long in business, show experience, size ofshows produced and names of other clients for references.
Experience selling shows similar to yours. If yours is a consumershow, you'll certainly want to know about public show sales experience,since the nuances of selling in that arena differ from trade shows.
Who will actually work on your sales team and their experience.
Proposed compensation.
Willingness to sign a non-compete, confidentiality agreement.
Make a short list Once you get responses to your RFP, how do you actually decide whichcompany is a good match? Know in your own mind what you expect, and whatyour show needs to prosper and grow. Here are some questions to ask:
Is sales expertise more important than knowledge of your show's industry,or is experience in the industry more crucial?
Do you want a company to have maximum impact immediately, or can youlive with a learning curve?
Can you contract out and still maintain the level of control you like?
Do they have sufficient staff?
Do you want to be a big fish in a small pond?
How does the proposed compensation fit with your budget?
When you've answered these questions, you can move on to the next step:narrowing the candidates to those who meet your criteria.
Test the chemistry It's a good idea to invite those in the running to your office fora personal interview. A one-on-one meeting is a good way to assess twoimportant intangibles: chemistry and trust.
Agree on compensation Compensation is tied to show sales revenue (exhibit space, sponsorshipsand other programs). The variables are the starting point, the range ofcommission percentages, and whether commission is on gross or net revenue.Percentages can range from 10 to 30 percent, depending on how many boothsare salable in the show and whether other services are contracted. Somecompanies also offer two-tiered commission percentages, based on whetherthe exhibitor is new or repeat.
Some outsource companies ask for a retainer which is paid up-front;some ask for a draw against commission based on estimated revenue. Somealso negotiate incentives over and above commission when contractual salesgoals are exceeded. Typically, the more you contract out to a single contractor,the lower the sales commission percentage. Other contracted services arepriced separately from the sales function.
Most outsource companies charge back out-of-pocket expenses, such aspostage, telephone expenses and faxes. Some charge back on-site expenses.Expenses are billed monthly, as are commission payments based on the amountof revenue received in that month.
Draw up a contract The consensus is that simple is better when it comes to the contract.A one- or two-page letter of agreement will suffice in most situations.Regardless of its length, however, you should feel confident that the contractcontains the full understanding of both parties' commitment. As with anycontract, have your lawyer review it.
While contract details vary widely, certain items need to be includedfor everyone's benefit, such as: specific terms of compensation; contractor'sresponsibilities; any exclusions; period of time the contract is in effect;an "escape" clause; and a non-compete, confidentiality clause.Including sales goals and performance standards in the contract has notbeen a major concern for either show managers or contractors. Some do,some don't. Of course, if you've agreed to pay incentives, you should makesure those details are stated in the contract.
Monitor sales activity Communication is essential for both you and your contractor. Ask yourcontractor to report sales activity with whatever frequency keeps you inyour "comfort zone." Most are agreeable to giving you daily,weekly or monthly reports, or any combination thereof. If sales are notmeeting expectations, talk with the contractor to find out if there's aproblem.
Ask the contractor to designate someone on his/her staff who is flexible,fast and detail-oriented to act as your point person -- someone who canrespond to any question or need you have.
Growing the relationship
For show managers, it's important that outsource exhibit salespeoplebecome a seamless extension of the home office. "It's critical,"Oregon Restaurant Association's Parker emphasizes, "that they careabout the overall strength of the show beyond just booth sales. It's notabout how many booths you can sell this year, it's about how you can helpthe exhibitors -- whether its helping them keep their drayage costs downor increasing sales at the show."
Andrea Saris, Director of Meetings and Conventions for the AmericanAssociation of School Administrators in Arlington, VA, says that in thetransition period following a reorganization, the association found itnecessary to outsource booth sales for their 1995 show. The sales functionhas since been brought back in-house and a person hired for booth sales.
"We did it for a year," she says, "because we didn'tknow what direction we'd be taking. But, if you're going to outsource,you need to be committed to it for more than one year -- to see resultsand for the exhibitors to feel comfortable. One year will not be beneficial.You need to give it at least two or three, maybe even four years."
Stay informed with Expo's weekly e-newsletter: Get daily industry news via RSS What is RSS?